Colette's Blog

The Calorie Conundrum

November 9, 2014

One of the biggest misconceptions among low-carb dieters is that you can eat whatever you want as long as it’s low carb. I’ve had countless clients come to me, complaining that Atkins isn’t working. When I ask what they are eating, they list a day’s worth of high-protein, high-fat food (which rarely includes vegetables and which typically totals to about 4,000 calories a day).

No wonder it didn’t work.

It’s true that Dr. Atkins and many low-carb experts told us not to worry about counting calories in the beginning—but that doesn’t mean that calories don’t count. Because they do. If you eat too much of anything (even food low in carbs), you will not lose weight. And you can also eat too few calories, which will slow down your metabolism, putting the brakes on your weight loss.

The reason for the original advice about not counting calories had to do with the fact that a low-carb approach concentrates on managing blood sugar and insulin. You are encouraged to eat whole foods—protein such as chicken, beef, pork and fish, healthy fats such as olive oil, avocado, butter, and fiber from vegetables—that naturally satiate your appetite and send hormonal signals to your brain that you’re full. That’s why it’s easier to stay on a lower-carb diet featuring whole foods than a high-carb diet full of processed food, which stimulates hunger and cravings.

And that’s why we tell you, in the beginning, don’t worry about calories. Just worry about eating the right kinds of foods and your appetite will, hopefully, take care of itself.

But because calories are not the whole picture—the way they have been in many other weight-loss programs—does not mean they’re out of the show. They’ve just been moved from a starring role to that of a supporting—but important—player.

This was never better illustrated than in a study done a while ago at Harvard University by Dr. Penelope Greene. Dr. Green took three groups and divided them into three different diets. Group 1 got 1,500 calories of low-fat food. Group 2 got 1,800 calories of low-carb food. (I’ll tell you about Group 3 in a minute). Group 2—the low-carb higher-calorie group—lost more weight. (If it was all about calories, the higher-calorie low-carb group should have gained weight, not won the weight-loss contest.)

But then Dr. Greene threw in a third group. The third group also got low-carb food, but this time they got the same lower calorie amount that the low-fat group got: 1,500 calories.

And this group—the lower-calorie, low-carb group—lost the most amount of weight of all.

The point is: Calories aren’t the whole story—but they do matter. If you’re stuck at a plateau and have stopped losing weight on your low-carb plan, maybe it’s time to do a little digging and see just how much food you’re actually consuming. Keep a food diary and make sure your carbs are where they are supposed to be and your calories are around the 1,500- to 1,800-calorie mark for women and 1,800 to 2,200 for men. (The optimal number is highly individual. This is just a sample range for the minimum intake because too few calories can be an issue as well.)

More From Colette

Going Green and Lean: A Low Carb St. Patrick’s Day Feast

This St. Patrick’s Day, you can celebrate the luck of the Irish with some culinary delights that may make you feel like you’ve found that pot of gold. You have your pick of traditional main dishes with a low carb twist, emerald-hued drinks and tasty treats. St. Patrick’s Day Entrees This year’s star of the

Read More »

Low Carb Lunches: Quick Fixes for Busy Days

Low carb lunches for adults and kids. It’s lunchtime, and you need quick, versatile lunch options that fit a typical day’s hectic pace. These low carb lunch ideas feature ingredients that do double-duty for kids and adults, ensuring everyone enjoys a healthy, satisfying meal. Low Carb Lunches for Kids and Adults Make the most of

Read More »

Food is Medicine

Why a low carb diet could be your prescription for good health. Many of our country’s top health problems, like heart disease, stroke, cancer and diabetes are linked to what we eat. These diet-related health issues also come at a monetary cost to our economy in the billions. While research shows how important good nutrition

Read More »